Another Kind of Isolation

45

By McKenna Woodward, OHA Public Policy Advocate

A prison sentence in Hawaiʻi can mean being sent to a privately run, for-profit prison in Arizona or Mississippi, thousands of miles from family and home. It can also mean spending more than 20 hours a day confined to a cell, with basic activities and human contact severely restricted.

The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (DCR) now argues complying with a law intended to reduce the second form of isolation may require more of the first.

In 2025, the legislature passed Act 292 to limit the use of restrictive housing – which includes solitary confinement – in state prisons and private facilities under contract with Hawaiʻi. Before placing someone in restrictive housing, prisons must show that the person presents an immediate risk of serious harm.

The law also requires prompt review of placements, independent oversight, access to medical care and legal counsel, more time outside the cell, and a clear path back to the general prison population.

These protections exist for a reason. Prolonged isolation worsens mental illness, increases the risk of self-harm, and makes rehabilitation more difficult. Those harms disproportionately affect Native Hawaiians because they are overrepresented in Hawaiʻi’s criminal legal system.

The Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA) serves on the working group established by Act 292. In December 2025, OHA presented an analysis concluding that DCR’s proposed amendments would undermine the restrictive housing law by weakening procedural protections, expanding exceptions, reducing independent review, and replacing enforceable standards with discretionary language.

Several working group members voiced similar concerns. Ultimately, legislation reflecting DCR’s proposal was introduced but did not receive a hearing.

Despite this, DCR did not comply with a key provision of the law requiring updated restrictive housing policies be provided to the Hawaiʻi State Correctional Oversight Commission (Commission) by July 1, 2026 – and now argues full compliance with Act 292 could require transferring additional paʻahao from Hālawa Correctional Facility to the continent to create space.

In June 2026, DCR transferred about 40 paʻahao to a correctional facility in Tallahatchie, Mississippi. The department did so without prior notice to the Commission, despite this action requiring an amendment to the state’s contract with CoreCivic, a private prison and detention center operator.

That raises a question: Why should a law intended to reduce isolation become a reason to send more people thousands of miles from home?

DCR points to overcrowding, staffing shortages, aging facilities, and limited treatment space.

Those challenges are real – however, a May 2026 report by the Commission found that Waiawa and Kūlani, Hawaiʻi’s minimum-security prisons, were operating at about half capacity while hundreds of people eligible for minimum-security placement remained in higher-security facilities in Hawaiʻi and on the continent.

The problem, then, is not simply a shortage of beds. Delays in classification and movement through the correctional system are also keeping people in higher-security facilities longer than necessary.

Distance from home limits family contact, access to legal counsel, cultural connection, and support for successful reentry.

Bringing incarcerated people home and reducing solitary confinement are not competing goals. Both depend on accurate classification, timely movement through the correctional system, adequate treatment, transparent data, independent oversight, and sustained investment in Hawaiʻi’s correctional facilities.

A law intended to reduce isolation should not become a justification for another kind of isolation.