Kauaʻi Contemplates an ʻĀina Kūpuna Bill

81

ʻĀina Kūpuna literally means ancestral lands. More recently, it has become a term to describe property owned in whole, in part or in trust by a descendant of the person who originally held title to the land.

Both the Maui and Hawaiʻi county councils have already passed ʻĀina Kūpuna laws to help keep these lands in local families; the Kauaʻi County Council is currently in the process of considering its own version of such a law.

Real property taxes in Hawaiʻi continue to rise driven up by ever increasing land valuations.

Kauaʻi County’s Annual Comprehensive Financial report reveals real property tax revenue increased 40.8% between 2020-21 and 2023-24.

In testimony presented before the council on September 30, Kīpuka Kuleana Executive Director Tina Aiu stated that while these rising valuations have strengthened county finances, “each year, real property taxes are cited by families as the biggest challenge to land retention.”

“This was one of the first bills that I started working on,” said Fern Holland, who was elected to the Kauaʻi City Council in 2024. “Community members active on this issue reached out to me about trying to address this issue of people being pressed out of generational land, and that’s how it started.”

The result is Draft Bill No. 3008, an ordinance to create an ʻĀina Kūpuna real property tax dedication. It would allow for Kauaʻi families who can trace their land back to before statehood (Aug. 21, 1959) to pay a minimal, fixed property tax for 10 years, which can be renewed for additional 10-year periods.

Qualifying properties must be owned by one or more descendants of someone who owned the land prior to statehood. At least one owner or trustee must live in Kauaʻi County. If the property is dedicated as ʻĀina Kūpuna, it cannot be sold or transferred for 10 years to anyone who is not a qualified descendant. Nor can it be used commercially other than for the sale of agricultural products from the property. The bill would additionally eliminate any back penalties and interest owed on unpaid property taxes.

To qualify, each family must document its lineage to a pre-1959 owner or lessee. “Currently, the kuleana tax exemption is the only tax relief option for ancestral ʻāina on Kauaʻi,” said Aiu. “What we’ve seen for families is that it’s a huge burden to find all the records that trace their lineage back to the person that originally received title to land after the Kuleana Act of 1850 – yet their families have been on that land for well over 100 years. To my knowledge, only 20 parcels have ever gotten the kuleana tax exemption on Kauaʻi. This gap can get filled in with ʻĀina Kūpuna.”

Just under 4 acres of kuleana land in Hāʻena have been in Presley Wannʻs family for over 100 years. “I’ve paid as much as $20,000 in property taxes on this land,” he stated in testimony before the council.

His daughter, Lei Wann, went on to describe how, despite multiple civil suits and probate cases confirming her family as kuleana descendants, they have been denied the kuleana exemption multiple times because they cannot provide birth certificates from the 1850s through the 1870s.

Maui’s ʻĀina Kūpuna bill became law in 2021. It requires a family to be able to prove the property was in the family since June 30, 1940. To date, 22 families have applied for the ʻĀina Kūpuna program on Maui.

Hawaiʻi Island’s ordinance was passed this year and requires the property to have been in the family prior to Jan. 1, 1926. “The fact that our bill only goes back to statehood may open it up for more people,” says Holland. “It’s not limited to kuleana lands – it’s anybody on Kauaʻi that’s owned their properties in statehood and is trying to hold on to it.”

While there is no estimate of the number of families that would be eligible to apply, Kīpuka Kuleana identified 54 potential family-owned parcels on Kauaʻi that currently owe more than $1,000,000 in penalties and interest from unpaid back taxes.

Each family would still be required to document its lineage to a pre-1959 owner or lessee through deeds, wills, trusts, birth and death certificates or genealogical verification. “Some families will find that burden difficult to meet, so it is highly unlikely that all 54 parcels would ultimately qualify,” Aiu said.

So far, two hearings have been held on draft bill 3008. “The committee meeting should be in mid-November, and that’s when we’ll adjust with any amendments that come up from other council members,” explains Holland. “It would be great if we could get it done by the end of this council.”